Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Abbie's avatar

I take Marianne's point wholeheartedly... but one of our biggest challenges is that we, as a country, disagree on what to be brave about... i am sure some people at the Capital on Jan 6th thought that moment was their call to bravery; not that I agree with them, I can just imagine they did. Having "moral courage" is so tricky when we wildly disagree on what is moral - just look at the abortion issue... As a first step to being brave, I believe many of is need to look inward and clean our own houses of our judgments, fears, biases, grief, grudges etc... otherwise when the call to be brave arrives, our actions may be misguided.

Expand full comment
Richard Kirtland's avatar

I agree the Ukrainian action is astonishing. I also know there are dynamics we cannot see or feel from here in the culture's evolving ethos. In the aggregate, Ukrainians have been through the mill for centuries. Borders have shifted, historical cultural practices prohibited, officially allowed languages changed. Many older Ukrainians that I know feel life was better during the USSR times, when everyone had free education, sponsored vacation retreats, and everyone was equally poor. Circumstances of life then nourished a depth of community we likely cannot imagine as we navigate our competitive consumerist theater.

Since '92, a clever few well-connected thieves have pillaged the country's resources. It is the same in Russia. There must be a deep rage in people who have been unbelievably taken advantage of by a privileged few. I think this rage is being tapped exactly now.

When I was in Ukraine twenty-plus years ago, people told me they understood transitioning to a new socioeconomic order would that a few generations. Most, perhaps all, of todays brave Ukrainian fighters have no direct experience of those good old days when the USSR functioned well (even though from our coddled perspective it never functioned well). These brave people are declaring and defending their right to transition and evolve into self-determined statehood. They are a huge threat to the authoritarian tilt of the self-made new Tsar next door. It is this aspiration of seld-determination which is being so violently attacked.

I too pray I will have courage to resist those who would threaten our right to our self-determination here in the USA. All too often I feel like a puppet, and I do feel the rage building as my awareness of being manipulated increases. Thank you Marianne for bringing your invitation to become more aware, to transition and transform.

Expand full comment
32 more comments...

No posts